pink gingham dress shirt...need a tie.

meb110

New Member
Just purchased this shirt -

https://www.brooksbrothers.com/IWCa...color=PINK&sort_by=&sectioncolor=&sectionsize=

And while I love it, I'm at a loss for ties. While blue might work well with my poplin suit this summer, I want to wear this with a navy suit to an evening wedding in a few weeks. The light blue solid tie pictured here screams Donald Trump to me, and frankly, that's a look I'd like to avoid. Any suggestions? A small pattern? I think stripes would be way too much unless they were broad...What about color? Suggestions gladly welcome.
 

Dingo McPhee

Active Member with Corp. Privileges
Pink gingham says "casual" and navy suit says "formal" to me, so I wouldn't wear them together. But that's me.

For colors, I'd try yellow or green (especially pastels). Purple might get too "in between" the pink and navy, but it would depend on the tie.

For pattern, I'd skip stripes and checks as too similar. Go for solid (but you've already rejected that) or patterns like dots or paisley.

Consider a bow tie if that's your cup o' tea.

And DEFINITELY a pocket square to lighten up the navy suit.
 

upr_crust

Connoisseur
The tie shown with the shirt is probably the best choice for it . . .

. . . but maybe not the only choice.

In dealing with a shirt that light and bright (and patterned), you would need something solid, or with a contrasting pattern (you might be able to get away with a navy/white dot tie of some variety - the suit had better be plain, or not strongly patterned, certainly).

For a red striped shirt of equal difficulty of tie coordination, I bought a medium dark cerulean blue natte, i.e. baskweave texture tie (from Andrew's Ties, since they have solids in every shade of the spectrum), which seems to work - dark, but not too dark, affording contrast from both shirt and navy suit.

Hope that the suggestion is of use.
 

The Louche

Super Member
^

Navy with white dots would look really swell. Just make sure the dots are of a sufficiently contrasting scale to the reality of the gingham scale.
 

ZachGranstrom

Super Member
knit ties always look lovely with a gingham shirt.But if you go with a silk tie, I'd suggest a nice solid colored one, like a blue, green,or a burgundy tie.:icon_smile_big:
 
Last edited:

PMRuby

Active Member with Corp. Privileges
Agreed w/ the person who said the tie shown with it is a good choice.

Quite honestly, that just isn't a terribly functional shirt. The pattern is very casual, while the cuffs attempt to dress it up a lot. Plus, the spread collar further complicates the matter by making it harder to find the right tie. I personally wouldn't wear this informal-looking shirt (being both pink and gingham) with a suit (other than perhaps a light-colored poplin) and I am usually somewhat hesitant to wear french cuffs with, say, slacks and a blue blazer. So, in all, I have no idea what you should do; it will take a lot of work to pull something decent off.

Whoever suggested a bowtie is, in my opinion, wrong. Look at the collar of the shirt. It would look very odd.
 

Master-Classter

Active Member with Corp. Privileges
one of the few times something with grey and white work IMO. Even a black tie if you're feeling daring.

otherwise I go complimentary like a shade of red, or purple with pink in it.
try knitted navy with pink polka dots
even charcoal grey...


Here are some pic ideas:







or
knit+tie.jpg

quiet-green.jpg
 
Last edited:

meb110

New Member
This message board is great. Wonderful suggestions, so thank you so far. Keep them coming though...and I'm very fond of the shirt.
 

TMMKC

Honors Member
I disagree that the shirt wouldn't work with a navy suit. Granted, gingham is a more casual pattern, but the wide spread collar and the French cuffs do give it a degree of formality than the same pattern as an OCBD. I have a similar shirt in navy, and it looks just fine with either a navy or dark grey solid suit. However, I would never wear that shirt for a formal or evening function.

As most of us know, combining patterns is not always easy...and it's very much a trial-and-error "art" (rather than a science). IMO, the trick would be to have one of the elements (suit, shirt or tie) be solid.
 

PJC in NoVa

Connoisseur
I happen to own a couple of pink ginghams very similar to that one. My most "out there" dress shirts by far.

I like to team mine with a solid-black tie and a dark-gray suit, either solid or a simple stripe like this one from H-F:



The idea here is that the shirt is so strong, bright, and colorful, you tone the other elements down.

Aside from the solid black, I also sometimes wear an RL Polo tie I have that has pink flamingoes embroidered in a solid-black background. Something in a similar vein that might work would be this dark-navy tie w/ pink crawdads from LE:



Or this one in navy w/ white dragonflies:



And of course navy with fairly widely spaced pink polka dots could work:



As could navy with white dots:



PS: FWIW, I don't feel this is an ideal shirt for an evening wedding. A daytime wedding held out of doors, maybe, but this isn't really a great after-six shirt, IMO.
 
Last edited:

Horticulturalist

Active Member with Corp. Privileges
I have a very similar shirt, and would suggest either a pale blue knitted silk tie, or a yellow paisley tie. But all the other tie suggestions sound good, too. It looks like a lovely shirt, enjoy it!
 
Your email address will not be publicly visible. We will only use it to contact you to confirm your post.

IMPORTANT: BEFORE POSTING PLEASE CHECK THE DATE OF THE LAST POST OF THIS THREAD. IF IT'S VERY OLD, PLEASE CONSIDER REGISTERING FIRST, AND STARTING A NEW THREAD ABOUT THIS TOPIC.

Deals/Steals

Trad Store Exchange