never behind

Senior Member
886
United States
IN
Zionsville
Wow, what a great place. It was overwhelming - there was so much stuff just on the main floor. Ethan and the crew were great in helping me try on a large list of items. I happened to be in Erie, PA and the 4 hour round trip drive was totally worth it.

I’ve been pondering buying another suit. I’d love to hear thoughts on the fit. It seems to fit well off the rack with the normal adjustments. I wasn’t sure if the shoulders were boxy or not.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Flanderian

Connoisseur
24,322
United States
New Jersey
Flanders
Wow, what a great place. It was overwhelming - there was so much stuff just on the main floor. Ethan and the crew were great in helping me try on a large list of items. I happened to be in Erie, PA and the 4 hour round trip drive was totally worth it.

I’ve been pondering buying another suit. I’d love to hear thoughts on the fit. It seems to fit well off the rack with the normal adjustments. I wasn’t sure if the shoulders were boxy or not.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Thanks for the great pictures. O'Connell's is my kind of place!

Did the staff help you find your size? If so, I say, buy it! These folks know their business. And also get whatever alterations they recommend.

The critical area of fit is the shoulders, and these look good. This is a relaxed, traditional cut and fit, and I know some are unused to it, but I love it! Normal lapels, normal gorge height, normal button stance. So nice as to make me cry. Get it if you like it. This is a suit you can wear until you wear it out, and it's cut and steel blue color will be extremely versatile.
 
Last edited:

At Law

Senior Member
619
United States
Nebraska
Omaha
That's outstanding to see real live pictures. Especially being from Omaha.
I have purchased a few items over the years.
Would you mind picking me up a pair of Quoddy Canoe Mocs in 11D - Brown Chromexcel . Ha.
 

Matt S

Connoisseur
8,059
United States
NY
New York
Wow, that is more stock than I have seen in a long time. I'm very impressed with the look of this shop.
 

never behind

Senior Member
886
United States
IN
Zionsville
@Flanderian I was The only one in the store while I was there, so I had a lot of attention. I wish I had taken pictures of all the tweed I tried on, as I know how much you enjoy tweed. They were wonderful jackets; I’m going to have to buy at least one come fall!

@Peak and Pine When I walked into the back of the store (where I took the picture), the first comment they made to me was, “there’s a method to the madness.” It was impressive - they knew exactly where everything was located. “Can I try in a pair of cav twills?” They grab a ladder and boom, 3 pairs to try on.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Fading Fast

Connoisseur
10,338
United States
New York
NY
That's awesome - thank you for taking the time to post about your experience and to show some pics.

I'm just old enough (54) to remember places like that from the '80s when I started buying real adult clothing - many towns still had that style of men's clothing store. Even the old J.Press store in NYC (the one on 44th, not the later one that was on Madison) felt a lot like that as did Gorsarts (a quieter, discount competitor to BB and Press).

While Brooks Brothers was always a bit more manicured, back in the '80s, it had tables piled high with merchandise and plenty of shelves and cubbies also pretty stuffed.

That, to me, is what a real men's store should look and feel (and smell - a mixture of clothing fibers, dust and authenticity) like.

Love the suit you got - great shade of blue - enjoy and thank you again.
 

eagle2250

Connoisseur/Curmudgeon Emeritus - Moderator
32,300
Harmony, FL
United States
Florida
Harmony
I don't believe there is any other men's store from which I have purchased as many garments online, as I have from O'Connell's. "Ethan and the crew" (I think they are brothers) really do know their 'stuff' and have seamlessly guided me through my purchases as to size required, color, pattern and textural compatibility, etc....and it is but a single order that has had to be returned for a different size. But alas, I have yet to set foot in the store, that being a sartorial adventure reserved for some point in my future. Thanks for sharing those wonderful pictures!
 

peterc

Super Member
1,358
United States
california
san francisco
Another nice thread here and WHAT wonderful photos. Echoing what Fading said, I too remember Brooks on Madison when it had tables filled with clothes. I had never seen a men's store with everything laid out like that before. Glad I was able to experience that.

To the OP: The suit looks excellent on you.
 

Semper Jeep

Senior Member
979
United States
Michigan
Bloomfield Hills
@Peak and Pine When I walked into the back of the store (where I took the picture), the first comment they made to me was, “there’s a method to the madness.” It was impressive - they knew exactly where everything was located. “Can I try in a pair of cav twills?” They grab a ladder and boom, 3 pairs to try on.
Thank you for the photos and you/they are right, there is definitely a method to their madness.

I try to make it out there once a year or so (this reminds me that I need to renew my passport so I can cut through Ontario and head back over there again soon) and I was definitely overwhelmed on my first trip there about a decade ago but you can ask for anything and they immediately know where to find it, even old deadstock stuff that you might be looking for.

I've never been to Cable Car Clothiers in San Francisco but I imagine it to have a similar, maybe less cluttered, vibe as O'Connell's.
 

Parapraxis

Starting Member
18
United States
Minnesota
Minneapolis
Thanks for posting this. I have not ordered from O’Connell’s yet but know I will be in the future. I plan to start with some of their sweaters but see they have a lot to desire!
 

Greenshirt

Active Member with Corp. Privileges
273
United States
FL
Ponte Vedra
Thanks for posting some pics of the store and the stocks they carry.

My interaction with O’Connell is through email
and online shop where I had the opportunity to buy the original Baracuta G9 jacket in British Khaki and Green, plus some ties and shirts. Ethan is indeed helpful as he walked me through.

Nice suit that you found. Traditional fit. You’re a lucky guy!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

eagle2250

Connoisseur/Curmudgeon Emeritus - Moderator
32,300
Harmony, FL
United States
Florida
Harmony
Thank you for the photos and you/they are right, there is definitely a method to their madness.

I try to make it out there once a year or so (this reminds me that I need to renew my passport so I can cut through Ontario and head back over there again soon) and I was definitely overwhelmed on my first trip there about a decade ago but you can ask for anything and they immediately know where to find it, even old deadstock stuff that you might be looking for.

I've never been to Cable Car Clothiers in San Francisco but I imagine it to have a similar, maybe less cluttered, vibe as O'Connell's.
Is a passport now required for a US citizen to pass through Ontario? :icon_scratch: We didn't used to have to do that!
 

Troones

Active Member with Corp. Privileges
480
Canada
Ontario
Toronto
Is a passport now required for a US citizen to pass through Ontario? :icon_scratch: We didn't used to have to do that!
It's been that way since 911. Back around the time that the Department of Homeland Security was established.
 

Doctor Damage

Connoisseur
5,855
Canada
Ontario
Toronto
Washington (not DC) drivers license can be endorsed for going back and forth. Coming back is the worst part. Seems like they would welcome US citizens back instead of treating us like criminals. Canada will take just about anyone. Especially if you say something about shopping.
They probably thought you were bringing back some cannabis from B.C.
 

Doctor Damage

Connoisseur
5,855
Canada
Ontario
Toronto
Wow, what a great place. It was overwhelming - there was so much stuff just on the main floor. Ethan and the crew were great in helping me try on a large list of items. I happened to be in Erie, PA and the 4 hour round trip drive was totally worth it.

I’ve been pondering buying another suit. I’d love to hear thoughts on the fit. It seems to fit well off the rack with the normal adjustments. I wasn’t sure if the shoulders were boxy or not.

Nice to see nothing has changed a bit since I first went there around a decade ago. If anything, the piles seem higher.