I have been informed, by email from Sebago, that the Cayman II and Classic models are made on the same last. I guess it's possible, as your experience indicates, that the original Cayman "I" was on a different last. That's good to know when buying from eBay.bluiewest1 said:For my $$$ the Cayman I's look a lot better than the Cayman II's. The brush-off finish never really develops a shine no matter how many coats of polish one applies. Also, the Cayman II is a larger shoe in width and length than an equivalent size in a Cayman I, apparently due to the different design. They look different and not for the better.