Synthetic vs Leather Sole

Discussion in 'Andy's Fashion Forum' started by dzd9fy, Jan 30, 2011.

  1. dzd9fy

    dzd9fy Starting Member

    I have always purchased leather soled shoes, I guess in part because when I entered the working world 20 years ago that was the sign of a quality shoe, at least to me at the time. Fast forward and except with what I would call disposable casual shoes, I continue to wear and only look at leather soled shoes. This has seemed prudent as I tend to wear the outsides of the heel and end up reheeling and/ or resole& heel shoes before the upper are old and aged.

    I notice now however that many AE and others have a large presence in the synthetic sole and I wonder how they actually wear and what can be done by local cobblers to replace the heels or such.

    Looking for input and advice...
  2. godan

    godan Advanced Member

    United States
    Northern Colorado
    Among my shoes are Prada, Facconable, AE, Sperry, Quoddy and (my favorites) HS Trask, all with rubber soles. Some are mocs, bluchers, etc. They all look fine and are suited to walking in town when the pavement is covered with snow, ice, crud, etc. Replacement heels on one or two pair were easily done locally. A heavy, clunky shoe does not necessarily look in balance with a suit, but falling on your posterior when leather soles slip on ice may look worse. There are plenty of thin, innocuous rubber soles. Technology and practice may be ahead of the ideas of some individuals who claim sartorial superiority.
  3. Broadus

    Broadus Active Member with Corp. Privileges

    United States
    South Carolina
    I just ordered a pair of burgundy AE Lombards. Side-view photos show a refined looking sole, virtually indistinguishable from leather. I wanted a nice pair of rubber-soled dress shoes for wet days, so I'm hoping these will do.
  4. Peak and Pine

    Peak and Pine Honors Member

    United States
    Mars Hill
    Rubber shoe soles are sorta like tires: when they wear down you usually chuck them. But you can prolong them with toe taps and heel cleats.

    They do look clunky when combined with a dress top, but look can super swell elsewhere. Not sure what the aversion is to wearing rubbers, Totes, galoshers (love that name) or boots over nice shoes in inclementnt weather, but seldom, as in never, see that discussed here.
  5. Leighton

    Leighton Super Member

    The AE Executive collection is completely resoleable. You can probably order custom AE's with the rubber sole.
  6. Jovan

    Jovan Honors Member

    United States
    New Mexico
    Peak: Dainite soles are supposed to be just as long-lasting as leather and look the same from the side. I don't think they're talking about the heavy soles they put on work shoes.
  7. eagle2250

    eagle2250 Connoisseur/Curmudgeon Emeritus - Moderator

    Harmony, FL
    United States
    Base your decisions as to the soling materials you select for your shoes, upon the type of walking surfaces on which they will be worn. That way you can lessen the chances of falling and "busting your rumpasauras," as my youngest grandson likes to call it! All the rest is simply rubbish!
  8. Cruiser

    Cruiser Connoisseur

    United States
    Spring Hill
    I suspect that it's just part of the ongoing trend toward a more minimalistic approach to clothing. Over the past 300 years or so there has been a steady march in the direction of more simple, less complicated attire for both men and women. If one item will do what it once took two items to accomplish, folks will usually gravitate to that one item.

    Personally I would prefer to not reach my destination and then have to deal with a pair of galoshers, especially if the weather was much nicer when I left later on that day. I remember wearing these things as a kid and I didn't like them them.

  9. dzd9fy

    dzd9fy Starting Member

    So anyone have any experience with re-heeling a composite sole? I ask as I tend to go through heels way before the sole and have yet to find a tap that did not look like I accidentally stepped on something or that lasts!
  10. The Rambler

    The Rambler Honors Member

    I've had it done on lightweight rubber/composite soles with an articulated heel (though one-piece bottom). The shoemaker just slices it off and sticks on another heel, with very satisfactory results.

Share This Page