As David Mercer says, baggier is better. I don't like the skinned-rat look.
That's exactly the problem with this topic and many others: even the "experts" like Mercer can't seem to distinguish, at least rhetorically, between the garbage-bag fit and shrink-to-fit fit, as if no middle ground exists. Both extremes are absurd. I really with people like Mercer (and Boyer, and others) would when they are running their mouths take more reasonable positions. Anyone who has spent too much time on clothing will understand what they're saying, but they are not helping rookies who don't know they're joking around.I guess you only consider the extremes as options.